Brute Reason

A collection of thoughts about psychology, social justice, and anything else I give a shit about. freethoughtblogs.com/brutereason

Topics: feminism / psychology / lgbtq / sex / politics / abortion / health / mental illness / language / depression / sexism / sexual assault / fashion / racism / education / social justice

my actual writing, if you're curious

The damnably difficult thing about all of this, of course, is that you can’t presume that both are innocent at the same time. One of them must be saying something that is not true. But “he said, she said” doesn’t resolve to “let’s start by assume she’s lying,” except in a rape culture, and if you are presuming his innocence by presuming her mendacity, you are rape cultured. It works both ways, or should: if one of them has to be lying for the other to be telling the truth, then presuming the innocence of one produces a presumption of the other’s guilt. And Woody Allen cannot be presumed to be innocent of molesting a child unless she is presumed to be lying to us. His presumption of innocence can only be built on the presumption that her words have no credibility, independent of other (real) evidence, which is to say, the presumption that her words are not evidence. If you want to vigorously claim ignorance–to assert that we can never know what happened, in that attic–then you must ground that lack of knowledge in the presumption that what she has said doesn’t count, and we cannot believe her story.

  1. allthegeekythings reblogged this from carson-blog
  2. takingbackshannon reblogged this from carson-blog
  3. carson-blog reblogged this from recoveryandmentalhealth
  4. yoursocialconstructsareshowing reblogged this from brutereason
  5. collegefreshwoman17 reblogged this from feminismandhappiness
  6. nevermind-the-buttocks reblogged this from recoveryandmentalhealth
  7. lilwitch reblogged this from recoveryandmentalhealth
  8. pig-along reblogged this from feminismandhappiness
  9. aswegazeintothedarkness reblogged this from othilaodal
  10. froufroufemme reblogged this from recoveryandmentalhealth
  11. arcaine reblogged this from recoveryandmentalhealth
  12. edensfalling reblogged this from recoveryandmentalhealth
  13. othilaodal reblogged this from recoveryandmentalhealth
  14. lost-kittenn reblogged this from recoveryandmentalhealth
  15. recoveryandmentalhealth reblogged this from feminismandhappiness
  16. sulthind reblogged this from feminismandhappiness
  17. cetaceasong reblogged this from feminismandhappiness
  18. coldmorningsun reblogged this from feminismandhappiness
  19. cinderanne reblogged this from feminismandhappiness
  20. timethekidgotfree reblogged this from thesearemyheartsongs
  21. thesearemyheartsongs reblogged this from feminismandhappiness
  22. feminismandhappiness reblogged this from brutereason
  23. thisday-undone reblogged this from brutereason

blog comments powered by Disqus
Ultralite Powered by Tumblr | Designed by:Doinwork